One of the most fiercely debated topics among serious overlanders is the decision to choose between sleeping in a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car.
While each option offers its own set of advantages and drawbacks, your answer will depend on your preferences, vehicle type, and the nature of your adventure you plan to undertake.
We are going to guide you through the benefits and challenges of camping in a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car to help you make an informed decision. Let’s begin with the case for rooftop tents.
{Shop Renlicon Overlanding Products}
The Case for Rooftop Tents
Rooftop tents have surged in popularity within the overlanding community, and for good reason!. There are dozens of benefits to sleeping in a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car.
Here are a few of those reasons and why they are so popular:
Comfort and Elevated Sleeping Position
Rooftop tents provide a level of comfort that’s hard to match when compared to other ground camping options. If your rooftop tent offers a built-in mattress, your rooftop tent camping experience can offer a comfortable night’s sleep.
Roof top tents also provide an elevated sleeping platform, meaning you’re off the ground and away from any critters or damp conditions.
For a taller person wondering how to sleep in a car, a rooftop tent might be the way to go.
Space-Saving and Interior Storage
One of the primary benefits of a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car is that they free up the interior space of your vehicle.
With your sleeping arrangements on top, the inside of your car remains available for storing gear, food, and other essentials.
Camping Flexibility
Car camping rooftop tents allow you to set up camp anywhere your vehicle can go.
A rooftop tent provides flexibility in where you can sleep. This adaptability makes it easier to find a safe and comfortable place to rest for the night when compared to sleeping in the car.
Of course, when only considering the benefits of rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car, there isn’t much difference in this category. Both allow you to camp anywhere your vehicle can access.
Protection from the Elements
Car camping rooftop tents are designed to withstand a variety of weather conditions, including rain, wind, and even snow.
Many rooftop tents come with weather-resistant materials, built-in rainflies, and good ventilation to keep you dry and comfortable in most situations.
Again, when comparing camping in a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car, the protection offered isn’t much different between the two options.
However, car camping might be able to offer better protection from harsher elements because you will be in the safety of your car.
Cons to Consider
While car camping rooftop tents have their perks, there are also some downsides to consider.
The tents can be expensive, ranging from a few hundred to several thousand dollars. They add significant weight to your vehicle, which can affect fuel efficiency and handling.
Additionally, setting up and packing away a car camping rooftop tent can be time-consuming, and once it’s set up, your vehicle becomes immobile until you’re ready to move again.
Some of the benefits of rooftop tent camping may also be features of sleeping in car.
In fact, in some cases sleeping in car may provide a better experience than that offered by a rooftop tent: for example, temperature control, weather resistance, and camping flexibility are all better achieved by sleeping in car.
Ultimately the decision will come down to your personal preference.
Three Great Rooftop Tent Options
Here are three excellent options if you decide to choose to sleep in a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car on your next overlanding adventure.
Each of these offering unique pros and cons.
1. Thule Approach Rooftop Tent (Best Overall)
The Thule Approach Rooftop Tent stands out as the best overall choice for its combination of space, ventilation, and ease of setup.
This four-season tent offers a 95-inch by 56-inch floor area, which is a bit narrower but longer than a queen-size mattress, providing ample space for two campers and gear.
The large mesh windows, including skylight panels, allow you to enjoy the views and fresh air while staying warm during colder nights.
2. Smittybilt Overlander Roof Top Tent (Best Budget)
For campers on a budget or new to overlanding, the Smittybilt Overlander car camping rooftop tent offers great value without compromising on essential features.
Priced under $1,000, this rugged rooftop tent is designed to withstand four seasons of weather, with large windows that provide excellent airflow, especially in warmer conditions.
The tent's wide ladder makes access easy, though the mattress may require an additional pad for extra comfort.
3. iKamper Skycamp Mini 3.0 Tent (Best for Winter)
When it comes to camping in harsh winter conditions, the iKamper Skycamp Mini 3.0 Tent is the top choice.
This premium rooftop tent is built to handle snow, wind, and cold temperatures, thanks to its thick poly-cotton blend canvas canopy and waterproof rainfly.
The well-insulated mattress ensures warmth, while the hard shell protects the tent when packed down, making it last for many adventures.
Each of these rooftop tents offers unique benefits, making them suitable for different camping styles and environments.
If you worried about figuring out how to sleep in a car, check out these options!
The Case for Sleeping in Car
For many overlanders considering sleeping in a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car, the latter option may appear to be the more simplistic.
It’s a choice that prioritizes flexibility, safety, and minimalism, and in many cases, provides more comfort than rooftop tent camping.
Convenience and Ease of Use
Sleeping in a car is as straightforward as it gets. There’s no need to set up a tent, deal with ladders, or pack up a campsite. For many overlanders, choosing between a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car, the decision is simple.
When sleeping in car, you can quickly move from driving to sleeping without the hassle of setting up camp. This is particularly advantageous on long road trips or when arriving late at a campsite.
Cost-Effective
Compared to rooftop tents, sleeping in a car is incredibly cost-effective. There’s no need to invest in expensive gear; at most, you might purchase a quality mattress or sleeping pad.
The decision to forgo the rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car can save you thousands of dollars in the long run. This keeps your camping budget low while still providing a comfortable place to rest.
Safety and Security
One of the biggest advantages of sleeping in a car is the safety and security it offers. With locked doors, you’re protected from the elements, wildlife, intruders, and other potential dangers.
In case of an emergency, you can quickly start the car and drive away, something that’s not possible with a rooftop tent.
Temperature Control
Sleeping in a car allows for better temperature management. This is a big considerations when choosing between a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car.
When sleeping in your vehicle, you can crack open the windows for ventilation, use mesh screens to keep out bugs, or even run the car’s heater or air conditioning for short periods if the weather is extreme.
This makes car camping more comfortable in diverse climates.
Weather Resistance
A car provides a solid, weather-resistant shelter. You don’t have to worry about rain leaking through, wind shaking your tent, or snow piling up on your tent.
Inside a car, you’re well-insulated from the elements, protecting you from all kinds of weather.
Privacy and Flexibility
Sleeping in a car allows for more privacy and flexibility.
If you need to relocate quickly or want to camp in an area where setting up a tent might attract unwanted attention, sleeping in the car is a discreet and efficient solution.
You can also leave your sleeping setup in place while you explore during the day, saving time and effort.
Challenges to Keep in Mind
For those of you wondering how to sleep in a car, realize this option isn’t without its drawbacks.
Space can be limited, especially for taller individuals or those traveling with a partner or pets.
It also requires careful organization to make sure you are comfortable. In some cases, you might need to crack windows or use fans to manage condensation and airflow.
Any use of the vehicle’s features that require power will also put a drain on your available fuel resources or battery.
When researching a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car, you’ll certainly need to consider a wide range of factors.
Final Thoughts on Rooftop Tent vs. Sleeping in Car
The decision between sleeping in a rooftop tent vs. sleeping in car isn’t a simple one. Both offer distinct advantages for overlanders.
Your choice will ultimately depend on your priorities, budget, and the nature of your adventures.
If you value comfort and the adventure aesthetic, a rooftop tent might be the way to go. However, if you prefer convenience, cost-effectiveness, and safety, sleeping in a car is a practical and reliable option.
